Old man walks through a cabin door and makes tea while a witness cannot get up
[name withheld] in Canada tells Art Bell that they and their boyfriend were working at a fly-in fishing lodge in northern Ontario/Manitoba. They report waking in their bush cabin needing the outhouse and being unable to get up. They then saw an old man walk through the screen door and make tea while they stayed unable to move. After he left, the lodge’s Aboriginal fishing guide seemed to know already about “the old man” and asked whether he had his cup of tea.
This clip comes from the source recording. AI chose where it starts and ends, so it may start or end a little early or late. The word-for-word transcript is not published. You can hear the source recording on the Internet Archive (file “Ghost to Ghost 2006.mp3”, starting at 2:26:18). Is this you, or someone you know? Ask for a correction or removal.
The story as told
[name withheld] says they and their boyfriend were asked by friends to run a fly-in fishing lodge about 600 to 700 miles north of Winnipeg, just outside the Manitoba border in Ontario. [name withheld] says they stayed in a log cabin about three quarters of a mile from the main lodging, out in wild bush, during a very hot August. [name withheld] reports waking and wanting to go to the outhouse but being unable to get up. [name withheld] says they felt pushed back down into a sitting position, and though they could move their feet, arms, and head, they could not leave the bed. Looking toward the screen door, [name withheld] reports seeing an old man walk straight through it without opening it. [name withheld] describes him as a full-body person rather than a ghost. He turned on the kitchen light, used the water pump and gas stove, boiled water in an old kettle, took the only cup and saucer, added sugar and a teabag, and sat squeezing the teabag. [name withheld] says they felt scared and pressed to stay seated. When [name withheld] asked who he was and what he was doing in their cabin, he told [name withheld] to sit quietly and let him have his tea in peace. [name withheld] then pounded their sleeping boyfriend’s back to wake him, but he would not wake. The man reportedly told [name withheld] to quit hitting him and let him sleep, repeating that he wanted tea in peace. After finishing, he carried the saucer to the counter and walked to the screen door. He turned and said he would leave the light on so [name withheld] could go and pee, then walked through the screen door. [name withheld] says they later asked the Aboriginal guide whether the guide knew local history or myths. The guide reportedly said they knew [name withheld] had seen “the old man” and asked whether he had his cup of tea. [name withheld] says the tea things were there and the kettle water was hot.
Reported events, in order
- 0:05
[name withheld] says they and their boyfriend were asked by friends to run or own a fly-in fishing lodge.
- 0:13
[name withheld] places it about 600 to 700 miles north of Winnipeg, just outside the Manitoba border in Ontario.
- 1:40
[name withheld] says they stayed in a log cabin about three quarters of a mile from the lodging, out in the bush.
- 1:56
[name withheld] says it was August and very hot.
- 2:27
[name withheld] woke wanting to go to the outhouse.
- 2:36
[name withheld] tried to get up but could not, and felt pushed back down into a sitting position. The same happened again.
- 2:51
[name withheld] could move their feet, arms, and head, but could not get up off the bed.
- 3:15
An old man walked right through the screen door without opening it. [name withheld] describes him as a full-body person rather than a ghost.
- 3:34
The man turned on the kitchen light.
- 3:37
He used the water pump, kettle, and gas stove to prepare tea, then sat down waiting for the water to boil.
- 4:20
He took the only teacup and saucer, added sugar, a spoon, and a teabag, and made tea.
- 4:57
[name withheld] watched, felt scared, and reported pressure keeping them seated.
- 5:13
[name withheld] asked him who he was and what he was doing in their cabin.
- 5:35
The man told [name withheld] to sit quietly and let him have his tea in peace.
- 6:02
[name withheld] began hitting their sleeping boyfriend on the back, fearing the man might undress and get into bed.
- 6:24
Their boyfriend would not wake.
- 6:34
The man told [name withheld] to quit hitting him, let him sleep, and repeated that he wanted tea in peace.
- 6:47
The man finished his tea, took the saucer to the counter, and walked to the screen door. He turned and said he would leave the light on so [name withheld] could go and pee.
- 7:25
After he walked through the screen door, [name withheld] went to the Aboriginal fishing guide to ask about local history or myths.
- 7:41
The guide said they knew what [name withheld] would tell them: [name withheld] saw the old man.
- 7:49
The guide asked whether the old man had his cup of tea.
- 8:01
[name withheld] told the guide the tea things were there and that the kettle water was hot.
- 8:22
The host commented that he guessed the man knew the caller and froze them to the spot.
Claims
Each claim is labeled as something the person telling the story noticed (observation), what they made of it (interpretation), something others told them (hearsay), or something the host said (host statement).
- observation· 0:13
[name withheld] says they and their boyfriend were at a fly-in fishing lodge about 600 to 700 miles north of Winnipeg, just outside the Manitoba border in Ontario.
- observation· 2:36
[name withheld] reports waking from sleep and being unable to get off the bed, feeling pushed back into a sitting position.
- observation· 2:51
[name withheld] reports that they could move their feet, arms, and head, but could not get up off the bed.
- observation· 3:22
[name withheld] reports an old man walked through the screen door without opening it and was a full-body person rather than a ghost.
- observation· 4:07
[name withheld] reports the man used the kitchen appliances and made tea, including pouring water into the kettle and turning on the gas.
- observation· 5:35
[name withheld] reports the man told [name withheld] to sit quietly and let him have his tea in peace.
- observation· 6:34
[name withheld] reports the man told [name withheld] to quit hitting their boyfriend and let him sleep.
- observation· 7:05
[name withheld] reports the man said he would leave the light on so [name withheld] could go and urinate.
- hearsay· 7:41
[name withheld] reports that the Aboriginal fishing guide already knew what [name withheld] was going to say and referred to “the old man.”
- hearsay· 7:49
[name withheld] reports the guide asked whether the old man had his cup of tea.
- observation· 8:01
[name withheld] says the kettle water was still hot and the teacup, spoon, tea bags, and saucer were present after the man left.
- host statement· 8:22
The host suggests on air that the man knew [name withheld] and froze them to the spot.
Scores, with reasons
An AI model gave these scores using a fixed set of scoring rules (scoring-v1). They are editorial judgments and rough guides, not the odds that anything paranormal happened. How scoring works.
This is a detailed, first-person, internally coherent story with specific objects and sequence, which supports moderate believability. It is held down by the context of waking from sleep and being unable to move, the lack of names or dates that can be checked, and the fact that the guide’s confirmation is reported rather than spoken on air.
Evidence for and against
- Firsthand testimony with a coherent sequence: waking, trying to move, seeing the figure, tea-making, trying to wake the boyfriend, later conversation with the guide.
- Concrete sensory and step-by-step details are given, such as the screen door, hook, lamp, kettle, water pump, gas stove, teacup, and saucer.
- The guide’s reported prior recognition and specific question about the tea are unusual details that support a structured story.
- The central event is not backed up by any second witness on air. The boyfriend is reported asleep and does not speak.
- The episode begins from a sleeping state with inability to move, a pattern that has ordinary sleep-related explanations.
- No lodge name, exact year, or documentation that can be checked is provided.
- The labels showing who is speaking in the transcript are often confused between the host and the caller.
- The exact year and the identity of the lodge are withheld or not stated.
- The host cuts off the story at the end.
- 2:36
- 3:22
- 7:49
What the model inferred (not said on air): My inference is that the story reads like a well-remembered, consistent strange experience rather than a vague legend. But the scoring guide discourages treating coherence alone as verification.
The evidence is the caller’s word plus claimed traces and a reported recognition by the guide, relayed secondhand. None of this is independently examined in the transcript, so it sits in the lower bands.
Evidence for and against
- The caller reports details that could in principle be checked: a fishing lodge north of Winnipeg, a bush cabin, an Aboriginal guide, and tea-making equipment.
- [name withheld] claims the kettle water was still hot and the teacup, saucer, spoon, and teabag were present after the man left.
- The fishing guide reportedly recognized the old man and the tea detail.
- No photograph, recording, logbook, or document is examined on air.
- The guide is reported secondhand and does not speak on air.
- The boyfriend is reported asleep and does not back up the event.
- The physical traces are described but not preserved or inspected by the host.
- The guide’s reported words are not confirmation on air.
- No outside check is recorded, and the cap of 50 applies.
- 8:01
- 7:41
What the model inferred (not said on air): I treat the hot water and tea things as claimed physical evidence rather than verified evidence because nothing was examined on air or documented.
The paralysis, isolated cabin, and commanding intruder create a truly unsettling situation. The long, almost domestic tea-making and the final remark about the outhouse lower the dread and keep it from being more frightening.
Evidence for and against
- The witness reports being unable to get up and feeling pressure to stay seated.
- An unknown old man enters a remote cabin by walking through a screen door without opening it.
- The man orders [name withheld] to be quiet and later tells [name withheld] to stop hitting their boyfriend.
- The setting is an isolated bush cabin at night.
- Much of the reported action is ordinary: boiling water, making tea, using a teacup and saucer.
- The final reported line, about leaving the light on so [name withheld] can go and pee, is almost a letdown.
- The man is not reported to injure [name withheld] or threaten physical harm.
- The caller’s tone of voice is not considered for this score.
- Transcription errors may affect the tone of the reported dialogue.
- 5:01
- 5:35
- 7:05
What the model inferred (not said on air): My judgment is that the contrast between the paralysis and the ordinary tea routine produces unease rather than outright terror.
The frame is familiar, but the long tea-making sequence and the guide’s tea-specific recognition give it a distinctive, low-key absurdity that sets it apart from many stock ghost stories.
Evidence for and against
- The ghost goes through a long domestic routine: pumping water, boiling the kettle, taking the only teacup and saucer, sugaring and squeezing the teabag.
- The guide asks specifically whether the old man had his cup of tea.
- The intruder tells the witness to stop hitting their boyfriend and later says he will leave the light on so they can go and pee.
- An old man figure, a nighttime cabin, and a witness who cannot move are familiar ghost-story elements.
- The guide’s recognition of a local old man is a familiar “local history matches” device.
- The published originality score, compared with the rest of the archive, is not calculated in this analysis.
- Some details depend on the automatic transcript, including “Keebler people.”
- 4:07
- 7:49
- 7:05
What the model inferred (not said on air): My originality estimate is provisional because the comparison with the rest of the archive is not calculated here.
Scoring confidence 0.68 · analysis confidence 0.74 · checked against outside sources: no · evidence available: The caller’s firsthand story; Claimed physical traces: hot kettle water, teacup, saucer, spoon, and teabag said to be present after the man left, not examined on air; Reported secondhand recognition by the lodge fishing guide, who does not speak on air; No photograph, recording, document, or outside check in the transcript. The originality score blends the model's score (72) with how rare the story's details are across the archive. This method is still provisional.
Ordinary explanations to consider
These are possibilities only. None is a finding about what happened.
- A hallucination during sleep, or an episode like sleep paralysis, could account for the inability to move, the pressure, and the vision. This is only a guess about the reported events. · [name withheld] reports waking from sleep, being unable to get up, feeling pressure, and seeing a figure while partly unable to move.
- Heat, tiredness, and the unfamiliar setting might have contributed to a vivid experience while falling asleep or waking up. This is not a judgment about the caller. · [name withheld] says it was August, “really really hot,” and they had woken needing the outhouse in an unfamiliar bush cabin.
- A living person in or around the lodge might have entered the cabin and been misidentified, though [name withheld] says he was not anyone they recognized and reports he walked through the screen door. · [name withheld] says they first wondered whether the man was one of the guests, “the Keebler people.”
What stands out
The reported intruder does not simply appear or vanish. He goes through a long, ordinary tea-making routine, and the local guide allegedly expects both the figure and the specific detail of his cup of tea. The mix of paralysis, a solid-seeming figure, and domestic tea preparation is distinctive.
Related stories
Matched by shared recurring details, categories, and wording.