Letter on deaths and reported hauntings at the Penfield Place in Illinois
The host reads a letter attributed to [name withheld] in Rockford, Illinois. It recounts the history of a house in north-central Illinois that locals call the Penfield Place. The letter tells of a series of deaths, a bride's disappearance and the later discovery of her dismembered remains, and strange events reported by later tenants. It ends by describing the house as still standing, decaying and in ruins. No document or second witness is presented on air.
This clip comes from the source recording. AI chose where it starts and ends, so it may start or end a little early or late. The word-for-word transcript is not published. You can hear the source recording on the Internet Archive (file “Ghost to Ghost 2007.mp3”, starting at 40:26). Is this you, or someone you know? Ask for a correction or removal.
The story as told
The host reads a letter attributed to [name withheld] in Rockford, Illinois, about a house in north-central Illinois known to locals as the Penfield Place. According to the letter, the house's “eerie legacy” began around the turn of the century, when a kitchen fire killed two small children and a servant. An undertaker then lived there. The undertaker's wife fell headlong down the main staircase, breaking her back and neck and dying instantly. The funeral director was found a few months later hanged from a maple tree in their own backyard. A newlywed couple named [name withheld] then bought the house, and the bride, [name withheld], went missing. Her jealous husband was suspected, but nothing came of it. A decade later, in the 1940s, workmen unearthed 17-year-old [name withheld]'s remains in the backyard beneath the maple. She had been stabbed, rolled inside an oriental carpet, and dismembered, and her missing limbs were never found. The letter says the house “went really bad” after that. Tenants reportedly experienced a presence that loomed over them as they slept, circled the bed, and touched their extremities. They also reportedly heard a soft voice whispering “Am I dead?” On one New Year's Eve, revelers reportedly saw a hideous black, faceless shape crawling across the second-floor stair landing. It rose up and glided away when someone screamed. The house was later converted into tenement rooms and boarding. The writer says they distinctly remember a young expectant mother living there in the 1970s who ran a high fever one night, miscarried in the house, and afterward gave birth to a stillborn, misshapen boy with no legs or arms at a nearby hospital. The letter closes by saying the [name withheld] place still stands today, decaying and in ruins.
Reported events, in order
- 0:00
The host introduces a letter from [name withheld] in Rockford, Illinois, about a house in north-central Illinois known locally as the Penfield Place.
- 0:11
Around the turn of the century, a kitchen fire reportedly killed two small children and a servant.
- 0:20
An undertaker's wife reportedly fell down the main staircase, breaking her back and neck and dying instantly.
- 0:30
The funeral director was reportedly found hanged from a maple tree in their own backyard.
- 0:40
Newlyweds named [name withheld] bought the house. The bride, [name withheld], reportedly went missing.
- 0:51
The jealous husband was suspected, but nothing came of it.
- 0:56
A decade later, in the 1940s, workmen reportedly unearthed 17-year-old [name withheld]'s remains in the backyard beneath the maple.
- 1:11
She had reportedly been stabbed, rolled inside an oriental carpet, and dismembered. The missing limbs were never found.
- 1:23
The letter states the house “went really bad” after that.
- 1:28
Later tenants reportedly experienced a frightening presence that loomed over them as they slept, circled the bed, and sometimes touched their extremities.
- 1:39
A soft voice was reportedly heard whispering “Am I dead?”
- 1:47
New Year's Eve revelers reportedly saw a hideous shape crawling across the second-floor stair landing in the darkness. When someone screamed, it rose up and glided away, black with no face.
- 2:11
The house reportedly fell into neglect and was converted into tenement rooms and boarding.
- 2:17
The writer says they distinctly remember a young expectant mother there in the 1970s who ran a high fever one night and miscarried inside the house.
- 2:30
She reportedly gave birth afterward to a stillborn boy at a nearby hospital, extremely misshapen and underdeveloped, with no legs and no arms.
- 2:42
The letter ends by saying the [name withheld] place still stands, decaying and in ruins.
Claims
Each claim is labeled as something the person telling the story noticed (observation), what they made of it (interpretation), something others told them (hearsay), or something the host said (host statement).
- hearsay· 0:11
A kitchen fire around the turn of the century killed two small children and a servant.
- hearsay· 0:20
The undertaker's wife died falling headlong down the main staircase.
- hearsay· 0:30
The funeral director was found hanged from a maple tree in their own backyard.
- hearsay· 0:56
[name withheld] disappeared and was reportedly found again a decade later, in the 1940s.
- hearsay· 1:11
Her remains showed she had been stabbed, rolled inside an oriental carpet, and dismembered. The missing limbs were never found.
- hearsay· 1:28
Tenants reportedly experienced a presence looming over them as they slept, circling the bed and touching them.
- hearsay· 1:39
A soft voice was reportedly heard whispering “Am I dead?”
- hearsay· 1:47
New Year's Eve revelers reportedly saw a hideous shape crawling across the second-floor stair landing in the darkness.
- hearsay· 2:01
The form reportedly rose up and glided away when someone screamed, nightmarish and black with no face.
- interpretation· 1:23
The letter states that after the body was found the house went really bad.
- observation· 2:17
The writer says they distinctly remember a young expectant mother in the house in the 1970s who ran a high fever one night and miscarried there.
- hearsay· 2:34
The baby was reportedly stillborn, extremely misshapen and underdeveloped, with no legs and no arms.
Scores, with reasons
An AI model gave these scores using a fixed set of scoring rules (scoring-v1). They are editorial judgments and rough guides, not the odds that anything paranormal happened. How scoring works.
This is a coherent, chronologically ordered story with named people and places. But it is a letter read on air that recounts local history and legend, and the paranormal material is attributed to unnamed tenants, not to the writer. Ordinary explanations (an old, neglected, subdivided building; sleep-related experiences) fit the reported events easily.
Evidence for and against
- A specific named house and named person: [quote withheld] and “17-year-old [name withheld].”
- An ordered sequence with dates: a fire at the turn of the century, a discovery in the 1940s, a recollection from the 1970s.
- The writer claims one personal memory: [quote withheld]
- The story is presented as a letter read by the host, not as the writer's own testimony on air.
- The strange events are attributed to unnamed “future tenants” and an unnamed group of revelers.
- The framing as what the house is [quote withheld] for is typical of legend, not checkable testimony.
- Whether the deaths and the discovery of remains happened as described cannot be judged from the broadcast.
- One sentence is garbled in the automatic transcript: [quote withheld]
- The writer's relationship to the house and their age at the time are not stated.
- 0:04
- 1:28
- 2:17
What the model inferred (not said on air): The component scores are an editorial judgment. Source proximity is low because the material is secondhand local history with one partial personal memory. Specificity is moderate because names and dates are given, but the paranormal events are undated and no witness is named. Internal consistency is high. Alternative explanations score low because an old subdivided house and sleep-related experiences fit readily. Calibration is low because what was perceived is not separated from what was concluded.
The only support is the letter's assertions, read aloud by the host. Checkable specifics (a named house, a named person, decades) are given, but nothing is verified on air, and no second witness speaks.
Evidence for and against
- Specifics that could be checked are supplied: a house name, a person's name, and decades.
- No document, photograph, recording, or record is presented or examined.
- No witness other than the letter writer speaks on air.
- The strange events are attributed to unnamed tenants and revelers.
- Whether any of the named people or the house can be identified or checked is not established in the broadcast.
- 0:00
- 1:28
What the model inferred (not said on air): I place this in the 11 to 25 band because checkable specifics are given but untested. The lack of any examined material or witness on air keeps it near the bottom of that band.
The letter piles up deaths (children in a fire, a fatal fall down the stairs, a hanging, a murder with dismemberment), an intrusive presence over sleeping people, a whispered “Am I dead?”, a crawling faceless black shape, and a stillborn infant described as having no legs or arms. The ending leaves the decaying house standing, unresolved.
Evidence for and against
- Intrusion into sleep: [quote withheld]
- The whispered question “Am I dead?”
- The faceless crawling shape on the stair landing.
- Murder and dismemberment, with limbs never found.
- The tone is archival local history, not a first-person encounter told in the present.
- No direct threat to the writer is reported, and the letter ends with the house standing, not with ongoing menace.
- The strange events are reported secondhand, which limits how immediate the story feels.
- 1:28
- 1:39
- 2:07
What the model inferred (not said on air): The score reflects the combined weight of the deaths plus the presence at the bedside and the faceless crawling figure, softened by the detached delivery of a letter read aloud.
The setup is a familiar haunted-house history: deaths on the premises, a presence at the bedside, a faceless shape on the stairs. But several details are distinctive: the whispered question “Am I dead?”, the dismemberment with limbs never found, and the later stillborn infant described as having no legs or arms.
Evidence for and against
- A whisper of “Am I dead?”
- Dismembered remains rolled in an oriental carpet with limbs never found.
- A stillborn boy [quote withheld]
- Stock elements: deaths in the house, a presence over sleeping occupants, a dark faceless figure, a staircase.
- The story follows a familiar local-legend structure of piled-up tragedies.
- The published originality is provisional and, in this archive, rests mostly on editorial judgment.
- 1:11
- 2:34
What the model inferred (not said on air): I set this above the stock-element anchor because of the whispered question and the echo between the dismembered body and the infant described without limbs. The overall haunted-house setup keeps it near the middle.
Scoring confidence 0.75 · analysis confidence 0.75 · checked against outside sources: no · evidence available: The host's reading of a letter attributed to [name withheld] in Rockford, Illinois.; No document, photograph, recording, or record presented or examined on air.; No second witness speaks on air.. The originality score blends the model's score (52) with how rare the story's details are across the archive. This method is still provisional.
Ordinary explanations to consider
These are possibilities only. None is a finding about what happened.
- An old, neglected, subdivided building with poor lighting could produce unclear shapes and noises, especially in darkness during a gathering. · The letter says the house [quote withheld] and was [quote withheld] and the shape was seen “in the darkness.”
- Sleep-related experiences (imagery while falling asleep, or sleep paralysis) could account for a presence looming over people as they slept, circling the bed and touching them. · The presence is described as appearing while tenants slept: [quote withheld]
- The material may be local legend and storytelling that has built up around a real house and real deaths. It is framed as what the house is [quote withheld] for, and the events are attributed to unnamed tenants. · [quote withheld] The witnesses are not named.
What stands out
The story combines a local history of deaths with a whisper asking “Am I dead?” and a dismembered body whose missing limbs are echoed in the later description of a stillborn infant with no legs or arms. The strange events are all reported secondhand. Only the 1970s miscarriage is claimed as the writer's own memory.
Related stories
Matched by shared recurring details, categories, and wording.