A voice and an arm on a hotel staircase, then news of a brother's death
A caller from Canton, Michigan, tells Art Bell that on October 7, 1983, while playing a band job at the Fordney Hotel in Saginaw, Michigan, they woke at the top of the hotel stairs, felt an arm around them, and heard a voice say [quote withheld] The caller says their mother telephoned the next night to tell them their brother had committed suicide. The brother then “visited” them for about a week and a half, which they describe as feeling a cold stare, and which they say comforted them.
This clip comes from the source recording. AI chose where it starts and ends, so it may start or end a little early or late. The word-for-word transcript is not published. You can hear the source recording on the Internet Archive (file “Ghost to Ghost 1995.mp3”, starting at 1:28:36). Is this you, or someone you know? Ask for a correction or removal.
The story as told
A caller who gives no name says they are [quote withheld] The caller tells Art they want to relate [quote withheld] and dates it to “1983, October 7th.” The caller says they were on the road [quote withheld] that they [quote withheld] had [quote withheld] and lay down, and then woke up [quote withheld] The band, the caller says, was staying on the hotel's second floor. The caller reports that they [quote withheld] and heard [quote withheld] The caller says that [quote withheld] and that their brother [quote withheld] Asked whether there were other visits, the caller says their brother [quote withheld] Asked what that was like, the caller says [quote withheld] The automatic transcript attributes the follow-up word “a presence?” to the host, and the caller agrees. Art asks whether the caller was comforted or frightened. The caller answers [quote withheld] says it changed them, and, when asked whether it tells them there is an afterlife, answers yes. Art thanks the caller and moves to the next caller. Some of the short replies are labeled inconsistently in the transcript, so who said individual answers is uncertain.
Reported events, in order
- 0:04
The caller states they are in Canton, Michigan, just west of Detroit, and says they have a ghost story involving their brother.
- 0:20
The caller dates the events to 1983, October 7th, while playing with a band at the Fordney Hotel in Saginaw, Michigan.
- 0:38
The caller says they finished the job about 2:30 a.m., had a couple of beers, and lay down.
- 0:47
The caller says they woke up at the top of the stairs. The band was staying on the second floor of the hotel.
- 0:55
The caller reports feeling an arm around them and hearing [quote withheld]
- 1:06
The caller says the next night their mother telephoned to say their brother had committed suicide and had died two days earlier, on the 6th.
- 1:24
Asked whether there were further visits, the caller says their brother visited them for about the next week and a half.
- 1:31
The caller describes the visits as [quote withheld]
- 1:57
Asked by Art whether the caller was comforted or frightened, the caller says they were comforted very much and that it changed them.
- 2:11
Asked whether it tells them there is an afterlife, the caller answers that it does.
Claims
Each claim is labeled as something the person telling the story noticed (observation), what they made of it (interpretation), something others told them (hearsay), or something the host said (host statement).
- observation· 0:47
On the night of October 7, 1983, the caller woke at the top of the stairs of the Fordney Hotel in Saginaw, Michigan, where their band was staying on the second floor.
- observation· 0:55
The caller felt an arm around them.
- observation· 0:55
The caller heard a voice telling them to go back to their room and go to sleep.
- hearsay· 1:06
The caller's mother told them of their brother's death the following night and said their brother had committed suicide.
- observation· 1:24
The caller's brother visited them for about a week and a half after the first experience.
- observation· 1:31
During those visits the caller felt a cold stare over them, which the caller and the host treat as a presence.
- interpretation· 2:11
The caller takes the presence to be their dead brother and the experience to be evidence of an afterlife.
- host statement· 1:47
The host states as a general principle that the dead “don't quite pass” and are not ready.
Scores, with reasons
An AI model gave these scores using a fixed set of scoring rules (scoring-v1). They are editorial judgments and rough guides, not the odds that anything paranormal happened. How scoring works.
A firsthand story with a concrete date, place, and time, but brief, not backed up by anyone else, and easily matched by explanations involving sleep and alcohol. The family details arrive secondhand.
Evidence for and against
- [quote withheld] and “October 7th.”
- [quote withheld]
- [quote withheld]
- A single caller, with no other witness.
- The caller does not address explanations involving sleep.
- The labels showing who is speaking shift in the short exchanges.
- 0:20
- 0:30
What the model inferred (not said on air): Component judgment (source proximity 22, specificity 14, internal consistency 13, alternative explanations 4, calibration 7). The caller's sincerity is not assessed.
The caller's word plus checkable specifics (hotel name, town, dates) that were not checked. No physical evidence and no on-air witness.
Evidence for and against
- A named hotel and dates that could in principle be checked.
- No photograph, recording, document, or second witness speaking.
- The hotel name and death date come through the automatic transcript.
- 0:30
What the model inferred (not said on air): A score of 11 to 25 for checkable specifics given but not checked.
A voice and an arm at the top of a night staircase, plus a suicide and a week and a half of a felt presence, is eerie. But the caller describes comfort, and the story ends calmly.
Evidence for and against
- Waking away from the bed in a hotel at night.
- A brother's suicide reported afterward.
- A cold stare felt over the following week and a half.
- [quote withheld]
- No threat, injury, or growing fear reported.
- The exact wording of the voice is uncertain.
- 0:55
- 1:57
What the model inferred (not said on air): A judgment of entertainment value only, not a claim about what is true.
A familiar visitation frame with a less common opening image: physical guidance on a hotel staircase and a death announced the next day. Much of the rest relies on stock motifs (a cold presence, comfort).
Evidence for and against
- A physical touch and instruction rather than a figure seen.
- The death is reported the following night by the mother.
- The second part is a generic “cold presence” description.
- The published originality is calculated separately from comparison with the rest of the archive.
- 0:55
- 1:31
What the model inferred (not said on air): A provisional model score. It is not adjusted by comparison with the rest of the archive.
Scoring confidence 0.58 · analysis confidence 0.65 · checked against outside sources: no · evidence available: The caller's firsthand story.; Named hotel, town, and dates given, not checked.. The originality score blends the model's score (45) with how rare the story's details are across the archive. This method is still provisional.
Ordinary explanations to consider
These are possibilities only. None is a finding about what happened.
- A confused state around sleep, or the half-awake state between sleep and waking, could account for waking away from the bed at the top of the stairs and for the sensation of an arm and a voice, which were experienced around sleep. · The caller says they [quote withheld] had [quote withheld] and “laid down,” then [quote withheld]
- Another person in the hotel, such as a bandmate or other guest, could account for a physical touch and a spoken instruction, if the caller was standing on a hotel staircase in the early hours. · The caller reports [quote withheld] and a voice saying [quote withheld] while inside a hotel where their band was staying on the second floor.
- The “visits” reported over the following week and a half are described only as a felt sensation rather than something seen, which is consistent with the ordinary experience of a remembered presence in the days after news of a death. · [quote withheld] and [quote withheld]
What stands out
The first reported event is physical guidance on a hotel staircase, an arm around the caller and a spoken instruction to return to their room, rather than a sighting. The death it is later connected to was unknown to the caller at the time. The caller also reports being comforted rather than frightened by what they describe as a cold stare over them during the following week and a half.
Related stories
Matched by shared recurring details, categories, and wording.