Mother sees an old woman in her armchair the night her mother died in Glasgow
[name withheld], calling from Greenfield Park, Quebec, recounts an event from their childhood in mid-1950s Alberta, where their Canadian-forces father was posted. [name withheld] says their mother, who had emigrated from Glasgow decades earlier and never returned, woke in the small hours and went downstairs. She reportedly saw an old woman sitting in her armchair in the living room. A search by their father found no one. The next morning, [name withheld] says, a telegram reported that their mother's mother had died in Glasgow the night before in a fire after a lightning strike.
This clip comes from the source recording. AI chose where it starts and ends, so it may start or end a little early or late. The word-for-word transcript is not published. You can hear the source recording on the Internet Archive (file “Ghost to Ghost 2005.mp3”, starting at 7:45). Is this you, or someone you know? Ask for a correction or removal.
The story as told
[name withheld], calling from Greenfield Park, Quebec, says they were an army brat, about 10 years old in the mid-1950s, when their father's Canadian-forces posting took the family to Western Command in Alberta, which [name withheld] calls a desolate prairie posting. Their mother had come from Glasgow, Scotland, roughly 25 to 30 years earlier and had never returned or seen her family. Contact was by airmail letters. One evening the family went to bed, and their father locked up and secured the windows before following. In the small hours, [name withheld] says, their mother woke with an urge to go downstairs for a glass of water, something she could not remember ever having done. She used the staircase light to descend. At the bottom of the stairs she reportedly froze. An old woman was sitting in her armchair in the living room and calmly gazed at her. The mother said she stood rooted for minutes, then ran upstairs crying and woke [name withheld]'s father. He came down, checked all the doors and windows, and found no one in the house. Next morning the father went to work and returned within an hour. A telegram on his desk said his wife's mother had died the night before, when lightning struck tenement houses in Glasgow, in the fire that followed. [name withheld] says their mother had never visited her, but that looking back, the figure would have been exactly as she would have pictured her mother.
Reported events, in order
- 0:07
The caller gives their name and location as [name withheld] from Greenfield Park, Quebec.
- 0:44
[name withheld] says they were an army brat, about 10 years old in the mid-1950s, posted with their father's Canadian forces unit to Western Command, Alberta.
- 1:14
[name withheld] describes their mother as originally from Glasgow, Scotland, and in Canada roughly 25 to 30 years, never having seen her family or visited Scotland. Contact was by airmail letters.
- 1:47
The family went to bed. Their father locked up, secured all the windows, and followed.
- 1:58
In the small hours their mother woke with an urge to go downstairs for a glass of water, something [name withheld] says she could not remember ever having done.
- 2:20
Using the staircase light, she reached the bottom of the stairs and reportedly froze. An old woman was sitting in her armchair in the living room.
- 2:27
The old woman calmly gazed at her. She said she was rooted there for minutes, then ran upstairs crying and woke [name withheld]'s father.
- 2:50
The father came down and checked all doors and windows. There was no one in the house.
- 3:16
Next morning the father went to work but returned within an hour. A telegram on his desk reported the death.
- 3:32
The telegram said [name withheld]'s grandmother, their mother's mother, had died the night before, when lightning struck tenement houses in Glasgow, in the fire that followed.
- 3:57
[name withheld] says their mother had never visited her, but that looking back, the old lady she saw would have been exactly as she would have pictured her.
- 4:09
[name withheld] mentions the previous night's replay of Art Bell's 1993 show, in which the host had summed up that souls visit friends before departing. The host responds along the same lines.
Claims
Each claim is labeled as something the person telling the story noticed (observation), what they made of it (interpretation), something others told them (hearsay), or something the host said (host statement).
- observation· 2:20
[name withheld] reports that their mother saw an old woman seated in her armchair in the living room when she reached the bottom of the stairs.
- observation· 2:27
[name withheld] reports that the old woman calmly looked at their mother, and that their mother stood rooted for minutes before running upstairs.
- observation· 2:50
[name withheld] reports that their father went downstairs and searched, finding the doors and windows secure and no one in the house.
- observation· 3:32
[name withheld] reports that a telegram on their father's desk said their mother's mother had died the night before, when lightning struck tenement houses in Glasgow.
- hearsay· 3:38
[name withheld] states that the death occurred in the fire that followed the lightning strike in Glasgow.
- interpretation· 3:57
[name withheld]'s implied reading is that the figure was their mother's mother. [name withheld] says the old lady she saw would have been [quote withheld] her.
- host statement· 4:35
The host's own assertion, offered right after the story, is that the departing would want to communicate with the person closest to them, to let them know they are all right.
- host statement· 4:57
The host presumes (the caller does not claim this) that photographs were compared and the figure's identity was “firmly made.” The caller never says this happened.
Scores, with reasons
An AI model gave these scores using a fixed set of scoring rules (scoring-v1). They are editorial judgments and rough guides, not the odds that anything paranormal happened. How scoring works.
This is a clear, anchored story with a concrete place and era. But the caller tells it secondhand about their mother, and the key identification is left to resemblance and the host's presumption. It fits the [quote withheld] range, and mid-range overall.
Evidence for and against
- Concrete era, place, and posting: [quote withheld] [quote withheld]
- A coherent sequence with detail of sight and place: staircase light, armchair in the living room, the father's search, the telegram.
- Answers to the host's questions stay within the same story; the story does not shift.
- Secondhand: [name withheld] tells their mother's experience, and the witness herself never speaks.
- The caller's own framing supplies the identification, since the figure [quote withheld] her mother, rather than any independent check.
- The host's remark about photographs and firm identification is the host's presumption, not a statement by [name withheld].
- Garbled passages ([quote withheld]) leave parts of the description and reasoning unclear.
- The labels showing who is speaking in the transcript are unreliable; several lines that are plainly [name withheld]'s speech are labeled as the host.
- It is not stated whether the figure was ever compared to a photograph of the grandmother.
- 0:44
- 0:58
- 3:57
- 4:57
What the model inferred (not said on air): The deduction for source proximity treats the mother, not [name withheld], as the witness. [name withheld]'s own childhood presence in the house is not presented as a witness role. The credit for internal consistency is moderate rather than high because two garbled lines prevent full checking.
This rests on the caller's word, with a few place and time markers that could be checked and a claimed document, none examined. That places it in the low range, well under the cap that applies without an outside check.
Evidence for and against
- Some details that could be checked are offered: mid-1950s, Western Command, Alberta, Glasgow tenements, a telegram on a desk.
- A claimed second person (the father) is said to have been involved, though not as a witness to the figure.
- No physical evidence is produced or examined; the telegram is only described.
- No second witness speaks on air; the father who searched saw nothing.
- No names, addresses, or record numbers are given that could be checked.
- Whether any record of the Glasgow death exists is not stated and is not checked here.
- 3:16
- 2:50
What the model inferred (not said on air): The telegram is treated as [quote withheld] which the scoring guide places below the 26 to 40 range reserved for evidence described as physically in hand.
A silent stranger seated in a familiar chair at night, a frozen witness, and a death notice the next morning give a genuinely unsettling feel. But the figure is passive, and the story ends on a consoling note rather than dread.
Evidence for and against
- Intrusion into the family home at night, and specifically into the mother's own chair.
- A watcher who does not respond, with the witness reportedly unable to move for minutes.
- The mother is described as terrified and crying, and the following morning brings news of a death.
- The figure makes no move, says nothing, and does nothing hostile. It [quote withheld]
- The event is a single occurrence with no repeat, escalation, or aftermath in the home.
- The talk moves quickly to consolation and theory with the host.
- The description of the figure is clipped, so how it appeared to a listener can be only partly recovered.
- 2:27
- 2:37
What the model inferred (not said on air): Creepiness is a judgment about the story as heard, not about whether anything happened.
A familiar frame in which a ghost appears as someone dies far away, carried by an unusual death detail and by the point that the likeness matched a mental image rather than a verified memory. Familiar frame with a distinctive detail.
Evidence for and against
- The distinctive hinge is that the mother had never met her family in decades and the sighting is matched to a death by lightning and fire in Glasgow tenements.
- The caller's own reading, the figure [quote withheld] her, makes resemblance itself the point of the story.
- A figure seen at the hour a distant relative dies is a long-standing, familiar ghost-story frame.
- Key elements (night, stairs, a seated elderly figure, a telegram the next morning) are conventional.
- The final sentence describing the figure's appearance is garbled, so a distinctive detail may be lost.
- 3:32
- 3:57
What the model inferred (not said on air): No comparison with the rest of the archive was available in this run, so the model's score stands alone and should be treated as provisional.
Scoring confidence 0.55 · analysis confidence 0.70 · checked against outside sources: no · evidence available: The caller's secondhand story of their mother's experience (they were a child in the house but do not say they saw the figure); A claimed telegram announcing the grandmother's death, described but not produced or examined on air; A claimed search by the father, who found nothing; the father does not speak on air; No photographs, recordings, or documents examined; no outside check performed. The originality score blends the model's score (45) with how rare the story's details are across the archive. This method is still provisional.
Ordinary explanations to consider
These are possibilities only. None is a finding about what happened.
- A dream-like image while falling asleep or waking up, during a partial waking in the small hours, could account for a briefly seen figure that is not found on search. · [name withheld] says the event came in [quote withheld] after their mother woke, and that she felt an unusual urge to go downstairs. That state fits a partial waking from sleep. Their words include [quote withheld]
- Expectation and a long-held mental image of a relative could shape what the mother perceived or later recalled. The host's own presumption about comparing photographs is not confirmed by [name withheld]. · [name withheld] says the figure [quote withheld] her mother, and that their mother had never visited her family. So the appearance matched an expectation rather than a verified likeness.
- An actual person in the house is considered and fits poorly: the property was reportedly locked and a search found no one, so this option is offered only to be set aside. · The father [quote withheld] while the caller earlier says their father [quote withheld]
What stands out
The story's distinguishing move is that the sighting is matched to what the mother would have pictured, not to a confirmed likeness: the old lady [quote withheld] her mother. The death abroad is said to have come by lightning and fire.
Related stories
Matched by shared recurring details, categories, and wording.