Aunt’s magician dream and the coworker’s husband’s matching dream
[name withheld], calling from Red Deer, Alberta, Canada, tells Art Bell a story they say their aunt in Ontario told them about five years earlier. She reports waking from sleep, going to the basement, and being threatened and chased by a man dressed as a magician with a butcher knife. This happened several times that night. The next day, according to [name withheld], her best friend at work said their husband had spent the night dreaming he was in the aunt’s basement dressed as a magician trying to kill her. [name withheld] says the story is true, and the host says it resembles an urban legend.
This clip comes from the source recording. AI chose where it starts and ends, so it may start or end a little early or late. The word-for-word transcript is not published. You can hear the source recording on the Internet Archive (file “Ghost to Ghost 2000-2.mp3”, starting at 2:34:24). Is this you, or someone you know? Ask for a correction or removal.
The story as told
[name withheld], calling from Red Deer, Alberta, Canada, tells Art Bell a story they say their aunt told them about five years earlier. The aunt lives in Ontario with her husband and son. She went to bed around 11 p.m. and entered the state between sleeping and waking. She heard someone in the basement, and since her husband was asleep, she went down. At the bottom of the stairs she saw a man dressed as a magician, in a top hat and tuxedo and with a wand. He said her husband and son were both asleep and threatened to kill her. He pulled out a large butcher knife and chased her through the house. She reached her bed and woke. The man was gone, and her husband searched the house without finding anyone. After hours lying awake she slept again, heard the same noise, and found the magician beside her bed. He said that when [name withheld] looked downstairs he did not check by the furnace, that he had been hiding in the heating vent, and again threatened to kill her. She woke again, and her husband checked the furnace and found nobody. She slept, and the same thing happened once more before they got through the night. The next day she went to work making bulletproof vests and found her best friend exhausted. The friend said their husband had kept waking and dreaming he was in the aunt’s basement dressed as a magician trying to kill her. Art Bell suggests it might have been a projection or a mutual experience and says it almost sounds like an urban legend. [name withheld] says there was some connection between the two, and that their aunt would swear on a stack of Bibles.
Reported events, in order
- 0:12
[name withheld] says their aunt told them the story about five years earlier. She lives in Ontario with her husband and son.
- 0:23
The aunt went to bed around 11 p.m. and entered the state between sleeping and waking.
- 0:38
She heard someone in the basement. Her husband was asleep, so she went downstairs.
- 0:47
At the bottom of the stairs she saw a man dressed as a magician, with top hat, tuxedo, and wand.
- 1:03
The magician said her son and husband were both asleep, threatened to kill her, produced a large butcher knife, and chased her through the house.
- 1:16
She reached her bed and woke. The man was gone, and her husband searched the whole house and found nobody.
- 1:42
After hours awake she slept again and heard the same noise. The magician was beside her bed, saying [name withheld] had not checked by the furnace, that he was hiding in the heating vent, and threatening to kill her again.
- 1:58
She woke again, her husband checked the furnace and found nobody, and the same sequence happened once more before morning.
- 2:10
The next day at work making bulletproof vests she found her best friend exhausted. The friend said their husband had kept waking and dreaming he was in the aunt’s basement dressed as a magician trying to kill her.
- 2:43
[name withheld] insists the story is true and says their aunt would swear on a stack of Bibles.
Claims
Each claim is labeled as something the person telling the story noticed (observation), what they made of it (interpretation), something others told them (hearsay), or something the host said (host statement).
- observation· 0:47
The aunt saw a man dressed as a magician standing in her basement at the bottom of the stairs.
- observation· 1:12
The magician pulled out a large butcher knife and chased her through the house.
- observation· 1:21
She woke in her bed, the figure was gone, and her husband searched the house and found no one.
- observation· 1:47
When she fell asleep again, the magician was beside her bed and said he had hidden in the heating vent.
- hearsay· 2:33
Her best friend’s husband had the same dream that night, of being in the aunt’s basement as a magician trying to kill her.
- interpretation· 3:19
[name withheld] says there was some connection between the aunt and the coworker’s husband.
- host statement· 2:59
Art Bell wonders whether it was a projection from the man to the aunt, or a mutual experience.
- host statement· 3:28
Art Bell says the story almost sounds like an urban legend.
- hearsay· 3:35
[name withheld] says their aunt would swear on a stack of Bibles that the story is true.
Scores, with reasons
An AI model gave these scores using a fixed set of scoring rules (scoring-v1). They are editorial judgments and rough guides, not the odds that anything paranormal happened. How scoring works.
The story is coherent and reasonably detailed. But it is secondhand (the caller passes on their aunt’s story) and contains a report within a report of a coworker’s husband’s dream. [name withheld] themself supplies the state between sleeping and waking, which makes an ordinary sleep-related explanation fit easily.
Evidence for and against
- Specific details: the aunt’s province, bedtime about 11 o’clock, the magician’s top hat, tuxedo, and wand, the name [name withheld], the heating vent, the bulletproof-vest workplace.
- [name withheld] attributes the story to a named close source and describes the aunt as very believable.
- [name withheld] was not present. The story is secondhand, and the matching dream is hearsay within hearsay.
- [name withheld] describes the aunt as being in the state between sleeping and waking, and every episode ends on waking.
- The host says the story almost sounds like an urban legend.
- Whether [name withheld] is the uncle’s name is inferred only from the magician’s line and is not otherwise stated.
- One threatening line is attributed to the host by the automatic labels showing who is speaking.
- No dates or locations specific enough to check.
- 0:23
- 2:33
- 3:28
What the model inferred (not said on air): Source proximity and calibration were scored from [name withheld]’s own framing (their aunt as the source; their remark that she would swear to it). The alternative-explanation score is low because the setting between sleeping and waking, which [name withheld] supplies, makes a dream explanation fit readily.
Nothing beyond [name withheld]’s retelling is offered: no document, recording, or object, and no second witness speaks on air. Names and a province are given, but nothing is examined or checked.
Evidence for and against
- A named caller and location ([name withheld], Red Deer, Alberta) and a named region for their source (Ontario).
- Several claimed participants (aunt, uncle, coworker, coworker’s husband) are named or described.
- All claimed witnesses are reported secondhand, and none speaks on air.
- No physical evidence, recording, or document is claimed or examined.
- [name withheld]’s only backing is a statement that the aunt would swear to it, which is not evidence.
- The uncle’s name, the aunt’s name, the coworker’s name, and the town are not given.
- The date of the events themselves is unstated. Only the telling ([quote withheld]) is dated.
- 3:35
- 3:56
What the model inferred (not said on air): The score is in the range of 11 to 25 because details that could be checked (names, places) are given but not checked, and witnesses are only claimed.
The story includes a knife-wielding intruder, a chase through the house, repeated visits to the bedside, and clear death threats. That gives a sustained threat and an intrusion into a safe space. The magician costume and the absence of any actual harm keep it short of the highest range.
Evidence for and against
- An intruder in the basement and later beside the bed with a butcher knife.
- Clear threats to kill and a chase through the house.
- Three repetitions in one night and an unresolved ending.
- The threatening figure is dressed as a stage magician, which listeners may find odd rather than frightening.
- No injury or lasting harm is reported. The household is “alright” by morning.
- The episodes are described as happening at the edge of sleep, which some listeners will read as dream images rather than a physical intrusion.
- 1:12
- 1:42
- 1:53
What the model inferred (not said on air): Creepiness was judged from the content of the story (threat, bedroom intrusion, repetition) rather than from the caller’s or host’s reaction.
A bedroom intruder and a nighttime chase are familiar elements. But the stage-magician figure, the hiding-place detail, and especially the claimed matching dream in a coworker’s husband make the combination distinctive.
Evidence for and against
- A threatening figure in top hat, tuxedo, and with a wand, carrying a butcher knife.
- The claim that a coworker’s husband dreamed the same scenario, including the heating-vent detail.
- It repeats within a single night, with the intruder’s words carrying information from the previous episode.
- The core structure of hearing a noise, investigating, being chased, and waking in bed is a familiar nightmare frame.
- The [quote withheld] ending and the host’s urban-legend remark point to stock storytelling elements.
- How new the story is compared with the rest of the archive can’t be worked out here. This score is a provisional judgment based on the content.
- 0:47
- 2:38
What the model inferred (not said on air): Originality was judged from the combination of motifs present, not from any comparison with other stories in the archive, which is not available in this excerpt.
Scoring confidence 0.70 · analysis confidence 0.80 · checked against outside sources: no · evidence available: [name withheld]’s secondhand retelling of their aunt’s story; Claimed witnesses (aunt, uncle, coworker, coworker’s husband) who do not speak on air; No photograph, recording, or document mentioned. The originality score blends the model's score (65) with how rare the story's details are across the archive. This method is still provisional.
Ordinary explanations to consider
These are possibilities only. None is a finding about what happened.
- Vivid images and dream continuation in the state between sleeping and waking. [name withheld] places the aunt in that state, and each episode ends when she wakes. · She got into that weird part of sleep where you’re not sure if you’re asleep or you’re awake, and each episode ends with her waking in bed.
- An ordinary household noise in the basement that was worked into a dream. · She heard somebody in the basement, and her husband was really asleep.
- The matching dream rests entirely on a report passed from the aunt to [name withheld], and from the friend to the aunt, with no independent account. Coincidence or retelling could account for the similarity. · Her best friend works with her. She got to work and saw that her best friend was extremely tired looking.
What stands out
The distinctive element is the claimed matching dream. A coworker’s husband is said to have dreamed the same threatening magician scenario, including the detail of hiding in the heating vent, in a different house. The intruder’s costume of top hat, tuxedo, and wand is also an unusual choice for a threatening figure.
Related stories
Matched by shared recurring details, categories, and wording.